A very good evening to everyone , it has been a very busy week for me in a good way and I look forward to deliver more .

This post is to ask the LeoFinance community what they think about engagement , contribution , posts , comments etc . I will divide the question into headers so that you can express your opinion easily.

Some of you already know that I recently started running an Engagement project in 4 tribes , LEO , STEM , CTP , SPORTS in which I rank top 25 engagers based on their comments quality and curate them. This is to make sure the people who put effort in commenting are getting rewarded .

But what all factors do I consider while calculating the comment quality

• Length of the comment
• Average length of the comment
• Number of authors you talked to
• Number of comments you made in the day

The actual weightage for these isn't revealed by me yet because it might be abused.

But how can we improve this ? Can we add more criteria ?

Length of the comment

Let's say I am talking about Economy of my country , I can go on and on saying , for example

• India started opening up it's market to the outside world from 1991 , it is only from then it started seeing the real growth and potential . If you see the history before 1991 , India wasn't doing good but after the 1991 economic reforms India just boosted its economy etc etc .

The summary of the above is - India wasn't doing well financially before 1991 but they did after the economic reforms that took place in 1991 ( Somebody who is better in English than me can further reduce the words but convey the same meaning )

So I took average length of the comment

Average length of the comment

Well if you have observed any of the ranking closely , you can see that average length of the comment matters in my project -

Ex -

If you see this gadrian has talked to 11 different people and has made 14 comments today but @erarium has made just 8 comments and talked to only 8 people but sitll @erarium is placed higher in the ranking this is because he has high average comment length . So not only talking to different people matters , it also matters how long your comments + average comment length .

Comments + Authors talked to

This is important too and I guess there is no explanation required . I will reveal a secret - Authors talked to has more weightage than comments made . Both matters but my intention is that people should engage with more number of people rather than 2-3 people talking to themselves.

This is what I have added today - a simple update -

Removal of URL

I observed that some people copy pasted URLs in their comments - not to abuse or anything - I often do it too . It is not fair to calculate that too in the length of comments so I have edited the code and removed it .

Code -

text = re.sub(r'http\S+', '', body_split, flags=re.MULTILINE) 

Without the code -
Output - Hey this is me sharing this link - https://google.com
Length = 45

With the code -
Output - Hey this is me sharing this link -
Length = 28

Sometimes the URL are so huge , it adds more length .

My next update in the code will be - Unique words

This is one thing I want to implement . If I comment on 10 people saying ,

Thank you so much , Thank you , that means a lot , Hey thanks buddy .

Although these are 3 different comments , there is no quality .
I will add this soon in my next update but first I wanted to ask you guys what you think about it.

Engagement Project - 25 users in all 3 tribes

Today if you checked the rankings , we had all the top 25 spots filled in CTP , SPORTS and ofcourse LEO .

In STEM there is an increase in activity but I have some ideas of how to push it further , I will implement them soon but it is a good news we have more than 25 users commenting in the 3 tribes :)

What do you feel about this ? What is quality for you ? Do you like the way I am curating ? Do you feel it is a good way to rank comments ?

---

I have started a proposal on Sportstalk community regarding this project - you can check it out here - https://www.sportstalksocial.com/hive-101690/@amr008/proposal-fund-my-sports-engagement-project

---

If you want to delegate , here are the accounts -

LEO - @amr008.leo CTP - @amr008.ctp
SPORTS - @amr008.sports STEM - @amr008.stem

---

Regards,
MR.

Posted Using LeoFinance ^Beta